TRENDnet TV-IP312 Review
Ratings
Category: Electronics
Brand: TRENDnet
Model: TV-IP312
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days.
List Price :
Discount: Check Price Here!
TRENDnet TV-IP312 Reviews
TRENDnet TV-IP312 Review by Garret Wilson (San Francisco, CA USA)
You'd think that a security camera would get Internet security right. This one doesn't even try.
The camera doesn't support SSL/TLS connections. This means that, every time you log in to the camera across the Internet, your password is going across in the clear, and anyone sufficiently interested can then use that password to log into your camera in your home and watch what you're doing or record their own copy. Furthermore, even without logging in, your communication with the camera is open for the world to see. This a huge oversight that has no excuse; it's like installing new locks in a house and leaving the key under the doormat.
If you try to set up email alerts to notify you of certain actions (e.g. motion detection), you'll find that the camera does not support secure SMTP servers. In other words, every time the camera sends email, it will be sending your email password in the clear, so that interested parties could later log into your email account and do whatever they want.
The product uses a proprietary Internet Explorer ActiveX control, which forces you to use IE instead of a more secure and standards-compliant browser like Firefox. But that's not bad enough. The ActiveX control apparently has no understanding and support of Vista NTFS permissions. This means that in Vista if you try to record to certain directories on the hard drive, it fails with a cryptic error message---even if the user has administrator rights. The only apparent way to get around this is to run Internet Explorer as Administrator (a special Vista super-user that has more rights than even a user with normal administrator rights), which is a bad idea in general and reflects the outdatedness of the implementation.
There is no way to tell the camera to start recording to the local hard drive when some action occurs. Sure, you can have the camera record to a "network hard drive", if you can figure out how to set one of those up. Or you can have the camera record to a USB drive hooked up to the camera, which someone can easily steal along with the camera. Or you can manually record to the local hard drive. But you can't simply leave your browser window open and have the camera only start recording to the local hard drive when there is some activity.
This would be a great little camera if someone with actual security experience had been in charge of its firmware. There is no excuse for these huge lapses in design, ruining what could easily have been a great product.
Update 2011-07-04: I was excited that firmware upgrade 1.1.0 build 72 purports to add SSL support! A closer look reveals that TRENDnet is utterly incompetent when it comes to networking. Yes, the firmware allows you use SSL for the SMTP server (outgoing emails), and this works. But that's the only good news. While there is now a configuration for specifying an incoming SSL port (default 443), if you try to connect with Internet Explorer 9 you get "Video is not support for HTTPS Protocol." Lovely. And if you connect from outside the network using Firefox (using port forwarding on the router), the Java applet won't load, giving "java.lang.ClassNotFoundException: ultracam.class". And of course the TRENDnet SecurView Mobile Android app doesn't support SSL in the least. Utter incompetence.
TRENDnet TV-IP312 Review by Rodger Barkus (Tualatin, OR United States)
After spending a lot of time with technical support I finally got the camera working through a router. The biggest problem (2 hrs) was actually ZoneAlarms firewall. It shut down the window needed to configure the camera with no notice. Turn off your firewall!
Now to the real problem for me. I wanted to use the stand-alone advertised email capability of the device. And I can't. The problem is that the firmware does not support "secure password authentication" required by my broadband SMTP If you are using Qwest Broadband you cannot use the camera to send email. You have to leave your PC on to send an email.
The documentation in general is marginal and the front line tech support folks are rookies. Nice but rookies.
TRENDnet TV-IP312 Review by Jace E. Mouse
You can't find a better device at this price point, but it does come with some annoyances and limitations.
Things I Like:
- Really great night mode via built-in infrared lights.
- Stable. No crashes or hiccups in the month I've had it.
- Solid construction. The camera and included mounting bracket are very sturdy.
- MPEG streaming video. Really nice quality, and a fraction of the bandwidth required by MJPEG standards, so there's less "internet lag."
- The ability to backup your settings is a nice touch, in case you have to reset the camera for any reason.
- Three year warranty.
- Support for sound. Built-in ability to listen (from IE, not from Firefox/Java) and the ablilty to connect speakers to "talk through" the camera.
This I Dislike:
- Camera gets "stuck" in night mode. Under normal indoor lights, the camera often continues to force itself into night mode, which results in strange washed-out colors. This is made more frustrating by software limitations that don't allow you to manually control which mode the camera operates in. Seems to work okay in fluorescent lights from office settings. Surely, this is all just a software glitch that will be fixed in an eventual software patch....I hope.
- Always requires a username and password to view the camera. So if you want to just setup a public camera, that's a frustrating limitation.
- Difficult to remove Trendnet's "branding" around their live video images - their logo, border, and other stuff. I think this can be done, but it's certainly going to require web developer skills and a bit of hacking to do it.
Other things you'll want to know:
- Focusing the camera is done via the focus ring on the front of the housing, not from within the software. So you have to be physically present at the camera to do it. That means you'll also need your laptop (or a friend on a phone) to know you're getting it right.
- TrendNet's site includes a "lobby cam" from their office, as well as a simulated user interface, and digital version of the manuals. That gives you a pretty good feel for what you're going to get with the camera.
- Viewing this camera from outside your home network is going to require some advanced skills in updating your router's settings. It's not especially hard, and there are instructions online to do it. But unless your router supports these settings and you're willing to tinker with them, many of the camera's features are going to be unavailable to you.
- The setup was not nearly as difficult as I thought it would be, based on other reviews. The need to connect it via a network cable to do the initial setup is a little annoying, but understandable and not too difficult if you've read through the manual. The manual is actually pretty well-written - you can download it from the manufacturer's site to judge for yourself.
More Reviews...
TRENDnet SecurView Day/Night Internet Surveillance Camera Server with 2-Way Audio TV-IP312 (Silver):: Technical Details
- Complimentary SecurView software: view and record up to 16 cameras simultaneously (32-bit only)
- Secure your home or office with high quality dual streaming MPEG-4
- Supports TCP/IP networking, SMTP Email, HTTP, Samba and other Internet protocols (Does not support SSL)
- Hear and talk to people in your camera?s viewing area through your computer
- Infrared lens enables day and night version (night visibility up to 5 meters)
- Item Dimensions: 4 x 3 x 3 inches; 0 pounds
- Brand: TRENDnet
- Model: TV-IP312
- Product Type: Electronics
TRENDnet TV-IP312:Limited time only!
Tags : Buy TRENDnet TV-IP312, Best Buy TRENDnet TV-IP312 Lowest Price, TRENDnet TV-IP312 On Sale, TRENDnet TV-IP312 Review, Great Deals TRENDnet TV-IP312, TRENDnet TV-IP312 Free Shipping! See also:
Acer AOD150-1577- Black Reviews
HP LJ 1018 Reviews
LaCie 706018 Free Shipping !
Cradlepoint CRADLE-MBR1000 Best deals!
SteelSeries 61009 Product reviews
BUFFALO WHR-HP-G54 Great Offer!
Canon 4205B002 Free Shipping !
LG CT21N On Sale!
Creative Labs 51MF1610AA002 Best price!
HP NV214UA#ABA Review
